(Last updated on July 14th, 2019)

Windows Defender or Avast, which antivirus software is a better pick in 2019?

Read this data-driven Windows Defender versus Avast comparison to make a smart decision.

Today’s internet is far from the safe playground you might expect it to be. These days, we are putting more sensitive data out there than ever before, which means you need a sturdy antivirus program to protect your devices and data.

New research from a well-known security firm has revealed that over 10.52 billion malware attacks happened last year. Ransomware, which is the most dreaded form of malware, saw a 117% year-by-year increase, and mobile malware attacks also rose by almost 100% during the same period.

The threats don’t always come in the form you expect. For instance, Microsoft Office extensions are the most common method that hackers use to hack into emails. Talk about wolves in sheep’s clothing!

The statistics convey a clear message: you need premium antivirus protection for yourself and your family. But the question is, which security software should you get?

In this day and age, free or low-end security products aren’t going to cut it. Their defenses aren’t strong enough to resist sophisticated malware attacks, and their definitions (or signatures) aren’t updated frequently enough. In fact, most free solutions out there don’t even offer real-time malware monitoring, which means they are only useful if you want to get rid of malware that has already done the damage.

So, it’s clear that you should invest in a premium security software for robust anti-malware protection and complete peace of mind. Also, premium suites come with a slew of advanced features and utilities that bolster your security and safeguard your privacy.

Important Note

Bitdefender Total Security 2019 EDITION

Best Antivirus Suite for 2019

(Out of the 54 security suites examined)

Editors' Choice Award Winner 

Overall Score: 9.9/10

SAVE 50%

00
Months
00
Days
00
Hours
00
Minutes
00
Seconds

Sale ends in...

30-day money-back guarantee

During the past few months, we evaluated and reviewed over 50 antivirus suites from the biggest names in cybersecurity. We did this so you can confidently choose the best antivirus software to protect yourself and those whom you love.

Overall, Bitdefender is our #1 antivirus software for 2019 (and beyond), because of its excellent, flawless performance in all independent lab evaluations, particularly those conducted by AV-Test and AV-Comparatives.

Right now, we think that Bitdefender Total Security 2019 (currently at 50% off) is the best antivirus package available in the market. Apart from providing excellent anti-malware protection, it offers all the advanced premium features and utilities that must be there in a high-end package -- and best of all, it offers excellent value for money. You can protect up to five devices (PCs, Macs, or smartphones) with just one license.

If you need protection for more than five devices, we highly recommend Bitdefender Family Pack 2019. It will cover all the internet-capable devices in your household with the Total Security suite, so your family is protected no matter what goes wrong.

In this guide, we’ll compare Windows Defender and Avast in a head-to-head battle. We’ll examine the strengths and weaknesses of both software and show you which software is a better option.

In a rush? Check out the rundown below to find out which software wins in each category.

A Quick Rundown of Winners in Each Category

1. Features
Winner: Avast. Windows Defender comes with all the essential features, but Avast’s security products – especially the high-end ones – have all the advanced features and utilities you can expect to find in modern antivirus suites.

2. Malware Protection
Winner: Tie. Both software are neck and neck in terms of malware protection, as evidenced by two different independent evaluations.

3. System Performance
Winner: Avast. Independent tests show that Avast is exceptional in terms of impact on system performance, whereas Windows Defender failed one key performance test.

4. User-Friendliness
Winner: Avast. Avast’s interface is intuitive and straightforward; everything can be accomplished with just a few clicks. Windows Defender’s interface could be improved.

5. Pricing
Winner: N/A. Since Windows Defender doesn’t have a paid upgrade, so there’s no comparison between both software in this category.

Short Verdict

Avast is the winner as it offers more security-enhancing features and extra utilities in its security suites than Windows Defender. Also, independent tests prove that Avast is better than Windows Defender in terms of both malware detection and the impact on system performance. 

Our recommendations: If you want to get the highest level of security and performance, there's no better choice than Bitdefender, which protects over 500 million computers worldwide.

We have reviewed and rated most (if not all) antivirus software packages out there, and we think that Bitdefender Total Security 2019 (currently at 50% off) is the best antivirus package you can buy right now. You can protect up to five devices (PCs, Macs, or smartphones) with a single license of this suite.

If you have more than five devices, Bitdefender Family Pack 2019 is the best option for you.

If you're just looking for Mac-specific protection, we recommend Bitdefender Antivirus for Mac 2019 for complete peace of mind.

Now, let’s go into the details.

1. Features

One of the best ways that we can distinguish antivirus software from each other is by looking at the features and utilities included with each package on offer.

First, let’s see what’s included in Windows Defender.

Windows Defender comes built-in on almost all PCs that run on Windows operating system. You can’t uninstall or remove the software, unfortunately, but it automatically turns off when you install a third-party antivirus program.

The best feature included in Windows Defender is the firewall that keeps your computer secure against malicious traffic. It maintains a watchful eye on all the incoming and outgoing network connections and denies unauthorized access.

Like most antivirus software, the software has a signature-based scanner that regularly checks for all sorts of digital threats. The software’s definitions (or signatures) are routinely updated to provide immediate protection against new and emerging threats — thanks to Microsoft’s cloud-based malware database.

Also, there’s the Find My Device function that lets you track down your computer if it’s been lost or stolen; this is particularly useful for laptops. You can also erase your data or lock your computer if you think that your sensitive data is in danger of being stolen.

Further included with Windows Defender is a suite of parental controls. You can use it to monitor the web activity of your children, restrict screen time with automatic timers, and block your kids from visiting certain sites or apps that are not appropriate for their age.

Now, let’s take a look at what Avast offers.

Avast offers different products for Windows and macOS. We’ll cover the Windows-only products first.

Avast Free Antivirus is the first product offered by the company. This suite protects against different types of digital threats, but you will not find any advanced security-enhancing features or utilities jammed into the suite. The freeware is better than having no protection at all, but Avast’s premium options are far more superior.

Next up is Avast Internet Security, the company’s first premium offering. This suite offers comprehensive anti-malware protection, plus an excellent firewall that is capable of protecting you from all sorts of threats and a junk email filter; this will keep your inbox neat and tidy and help you avoid having to wade through annoying spam and phishing emails.

Another useful addition in the Internet Security package is the Sandbox Mode. This feature allows you to run suspicious files or apps in a secure environment, without putting the health of your computer in jeopardy. The Real Site feature that prevents fake DNS routing from taking place is there as well.

Get Avast Internet Security

Another level up is Avast Premier. This package includes everything that’s jammed into the Internet Security suite, plus you get a file shredder utility; this allows you to permanently delete any sensitive files that you don’t want to risk being taken by a hacker. Webcam protection software that stops people from spying on you through your webcam is also part of this suite.

Get Avast Premier

Finally, there’s Avast Ultimate – the all-inclusive premium offering from the company. This comes with everything found in the previous suites, plus a full-blown password manager that allows you to store all your passwords in a digital vault, a VPN utility that lets you anonymously access content that is restricted in your geographic area.

The Ultimate suite also comes with the useful Cleanup Premium utility that cleans junk files, optimizes the performance of your PC, and fix annoying problems. 

Get Avast Ultimate

Features included in Avast Security Suites

For macOS, the company offers Avast Security for Mac. It comes in two versions: Free and Premium. The freeware provides anti-malware protection, along with web and email protection and WiFi network protection, while the Premium version takes things to another level by adding several advanced features and tools, such as multi-layered ransomware protection and the WiFi intruder alert feature. 

Get Avast Security for Mac

If you’re interested in Avast’s business-specific products, click here for more information. 

Winner: Avast. Avast offers more security-enhancing features and utilities than Windows Defender.

2. Malware Protection

Malware defense is critical when it comes to antivirus software. After all, it’s the reason why antivirus software exists!

Let’s examine the recent lab evaluations conducted by AV-Test and AV-Comparatives to see which software has better anti-malware capabilities.

AV-Test’s recent evaluations were held in April 2019. During the evaluations, all antivirus software were tested in three different categories: Protection, Performance, and Usability.

In the Protection test, Windows Defender scored a perfect 6 out of 6, showing excellent anti-malware capabilities.

Windows-Defender-protection-test-results-AV-Test-evaluations-March-April-2019

Avast scored a 5.5 out of 6 in the test, which is still a good score.

Avast-protection-test-results-AV-Test-evaluations-March-April-2019

AV-Comparatives is another independent organization that regularly run several excellent tests to evaluate the performance of different antivirus software. In their recent Real-World tests, both Windows Defender and Avast earned the second-best ADVANCED award, which represents good overall performance against all sorts of malware. Bitdefender and Kaspersky were among the products that got the highest ADVANCED+ award in the test.

AV-Comparatives Real World Test Feb-May 2019

Winner: Tie. It’s a tie in this category as both software have comparable results from two independent sources.

3. System Performance

Any antivirus software that slows your computer down isn’t worth your money. Good antivirus software provide excellent malware protection without putting a significant impact on system performance.

Again, we’ll examine the recent lab tests conducted by independent labs to see how much impact both Windows Defender and Avast put on system performance.

In the AV-Test’s April 2019 evaluations, Windows Defender scored a 5.5 out of 6 in the Performance category.

Windows-Defender-performance-test-results-AV-Test-evaluations-March-April-2019

Avast scored a perfect 6 out of 6 score in the same evaluation.

Avast-performance-test-results-AV-Test-evaluations-March-April-2019

In the recent performance evaluation conducted by AV-Comparatives, Avast earned the highest ADVANCED+ award, due to its exceptional impact score. On the other hand, Windows Defender’s performance was extremely disappointing; it came last among the 16 products that participated in the test and received the STANDARD award, which is the lowest possible award offered by the company.

AV-Comparatives-performance-test-results-April-2019

Winner: Avast. Independent evaluations confirm that Avast is better than Windows Defender in terms of the impact on system performance.

4. User-Friendliness

Another important aspect that we can look at is user-friendliness. Let’s directly compare both software’s user interfaces and see which one is better.

Windows Defender has a simple, minimalistic visual aesthetic. Opening the software requires several clicks; you have to jump through several hoops before you can reach the Windows Security Center, which is the primary dashboard for controlling the software’s features and operations.

The interface is neat and clean, and everything is laid out well. The left-hand grouping allows you to reach various modules and operations.

There’s no option to schedule scans, which may be frustrating for some people, but you can run different types of scans.

Windows Defender Interface on Windows 10

Avast’s interface is simple and intuitive, dominated by dark colors. Even those who aren’t computer literate will be able to effectively utilize everything that Avast has to offer.

When you open the software, you’ll probably see a large green checkmark in the center, which indicates that everything is okay. The checkmark will change to a red exclamation point if there’s something wrong. Beneath the indicator icon is a quick scan button that allows you to immediately begin a smart scan of your computer.

The left-hand rail organizes all the major features and into four self-explanatory categories: Status, Privacy, Protection, and Performance. All the major features of the software are just a few clicks away from the main screen.

In addition, there are customization options available if you like to fine-tune your experience. For instance, you can schedule scans to work around your schedule or lower the number of automatic scans to free up processing speed for other tasks.

Avast Interface

Winner: Avast. Overall, Avast’s interface provides a better user experience than Windows Defender’s.

5. Pricing

Avast offers a full suite of antivirus products, including a limited freemium option, while Windows Defender is a free program with no paid-for upgrades. So, there’s no real comparison between both software in this category.

Avast Free antivirus is just like Windows Defender in that it doesn’t cost you a penny. However, this freemium software offers minimal value. Avast Internet Security, the company’s first premium offering, costs $59.99 per year for one PC. Avast Premium, the next step up, costs $69.99 per year for one PC license. Avast Ultimate, the highest tier of protection from Avast, also gives you one PC license for $119.99 per year.

Avast Security ProductsPrices
Avast Pro AntivirusCheck Price
Avast Internet SecurityCheck Price
Avast PremierCheck Price
Avast UltimateCheck Price
Avast Security for MacCheck Price
Avast Business ProductsCheck Prices

Winner: N/A. There’s no comparison between both Avast and Windows Defender in this category.

Final Thoughts

Get Bitdefender at 50% off today

bitdefender logo
00
Months
00
Days
00
Hours
00
Minutes
00
Seconds

Overall Score: 9.9/10

Sale ends in...

Editors Choice Award Winner

Our recommendations: After reviewing over 50 antivirus suites from some of the biggest names in the cybersecurity landscape, we believe that Bitdefender Total Security 2019 (currently at 50% off) is the best antivirus suite for 2019 in terms of value for money. A single subscription of the suites lets you protect up to five devices (PCs, Macs, and smartphones) in any combination.

Plus, it comes with premium customer support and a 30-day money-back guarantee.

If you have more than five devices, Bitdefender Family Pack 2019 is the best option for you.

 

Related Comparisons

Avast vs AVG 
Bitdefender vs Avast 

Bitdefender vs Kaspersky
Windows Defender vs McAfee
Bitdefender vs Malwarebytes
McAfee vs Norton
Kaspersky vs Norton
Windows Defender Vs Norton
Bitdefender Vs Windows Defender
Bitdefender vs ESET
McAfee vs Kaspersky
Bitdefender vs McAfee
Bitdefender vs Norton 
Norton vs Avast 

11 thoughts on “Windows Defender Vs Avast | Ultimate, Head-to-Head Battle [2019]”

  1. I am an Avast user for the last 4 to 5 years. Avast was good back then but something has happened to it and I have stopped using it.

  2. I have been using Avast Internet Security for some time now. I am running a laptop on Windows 10. I have a question: Is it possible to run Windows Defender and Avast Internet Security at the same time? Would you want to? Looking at some of the settings in Windows Defender now, it looks like Avast Internet Security is managing those options at the moment eg the firewall options. Does that make sense? Is that a good approach?

    1. Yes, you can run Avast and Windows Defender at the same time. You can put Avast in the “passive mode.” But I am not really sure why you’d want to do that as Avast Internet Security is pretty comprehensive in terms of features and protection.

      1. The only reason I can think of why you might, is that one of them might detect something amiss that the other one does not. The downsides I see is that they might not ‘play well together’, there may be a performance hit, and you have to know about how to work with both of them, and maybe have to spend time learning and implementing getting both of them to ‘play well together’.

  3. In the section on impact on system resources, you conclude that Avast has less impact, but looking at the two associated tables, it appears that Avast performs significantly worse on all but one of the tests listed in the tables.Since Avast is said to perform better on the other testing mentioned in that section, is it possible that the two tables are mislabeled, with the lower table actually reflecting Windows Defender’s results, and the upper table (where the only “worse” score is for slower installation) those for Avast?

    1. Hey Scott,
      Thanks for your comment.
      These results are from the last year’s tests. Windows Defender performed much better in the recent test conducted by AV-Test and AV-Comparatives. I will update it very soon.
      Umair

    1. Hello Sagar,
      Thanks for your comment.
      If you want extra features and utilities along with great malware protection, go with Avast Internet Security or Avast Ultimate (if your budget allows you).

  4. Avast free you even say is basic but pay for the better functionality and then compare ‘like’ for like, I can cheat a test too. And the performance drop is worse for installing apps…Not sure about you but I would rather every day websites and apps run faster than the 1 time I install an app.

    Call yourself an objective writer? Well doesn’t look like it from where I am standing.

    I am about to uninstall Avast to use Defender…because it is SAFER… 99.3% means Avast would have GIVEN ME A VIRUS while Defender would have saved me.

    1. Hello Mike,

      Thanks for your comment.

      If you look at the independent tests conducted during the past 2 years, Avast Free has consistently outperformed Windows Defender in terms of both malware detection and the impact on system performance. It’s not a good idea to rely on one test and make your choice based on that; you should choose a software that has an excellent track record. Windows Defender, unfortunately, doesn’t have a great track record when it comes to performance in independent labs.

      And yes, we manually approve (and edit) comments to ensure they are in accordance with our comments’ policy.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *